I was inspired by Ann Reardon’s Camera Piñata Sugar Cookies . Instructions and template under the read more!
1) Eyes:
I started by making the eyeball disks. I used red hard candies and white royal icing but you can probably use all sorts of things: fondant discs, very thin cookies, melted gummy bears, M&Ms… Just make sure they aren’t sticky and that they’re bigger than the size you’re planning to make Duskull’s eye holes or else they might get stuck or fall out.
For my version of the eyes, I melted a few red candies in a saucepan and spooned small amounts onto a baking sheet. They weren’t super neat so I put them in a heated oven just long enough to spread out; keep a close eye on them or they might burn! I used a metal spatula to flatten out the smaller ones a bit as they were cooling.
Then, I used a small bit of royal icing to make the eyeball with a toothpick. Once the royal icing was completely dry, I covered the back with white royal icing as well, because the transparent candies weren’t super visible against dark backgrounds.
2) For the cookies, you’ll need chocolate sugar cookie dough and plain sugar cookie dough. I used this recipe for the chocolate sugar cookie parts and this one for the plain ones. You can use any recipe as long as they keep their shape as they bake. You’ll need a lot more chocolate dough than plain dough, about 3 times as much.
3) Once your doughs are made, roll them out quite thinly, around 1/8 inch. I think I made mine a bit thick, especially the top two layers, which made the eyes less visible than I would’ve liked! Just make sure the middle layer is thick enough so the eyes you made can move once all layers are stuck together.
4) Once you have your doughs rolled out, you’ll need to cut out these pieces for each cookie:
– 1 skull out of plain cookie dough
– 1 back piece from the chocolate dough
– 1 middle piece from the chocolate dough without the tail and with a space cut out in the middle for the eye
I made a template that you can use. The grey parts should be cut out and the dotted lines on the left column are just to show where the skull will be, don’t cut them out! Whether you print these or draw your own, cut out a set from and “trace” them with a knife on the dough.
5) When you take the cookies out of the oven, they’ll still be soft. Use this opportunity to fix the shapes as best you can with a utensil if they need any adjustments.
6) Once the cookies are cooled, use royal icing or melted chocolate to glue the two chocolate layers together. Don’t use use too much or else they might leak into the “eye space”.
6) Place one eye into the hole, and see if it can roll around enough. If the space isn’t big enough, you can use a knife to carefully scrape along the edges. Make sure not to leave any crumbs in there.
7) Use chocolate or royal icing once again to glue the skull on top of the middle layer. Let the royal icing/chocolate set and you’re all done!
Look at that boy!! He’s certainly up to something, and he’s ready for it! The dark background shows off just how pale he is!!!! (10/10)
Super Mario World (Boo Buddies)
Oh, there’s three here!! Already a great start! And look, they’re showing off how many different faces they can make!! You go, boo Buddies!! (10/10)
Super Mario 64
He may be pointy, but look at those amazing blue eyes! Don’t you just wanna stare into them for hours? Not as big of a smile as his predecessors, but that doesn’t matter!!! (10/10)
Super Mario Sunshine
Aaaaaa such a long tongue! And those teeth make the expression so adorable! They also like to take naps, so be sure not to wake them!!! (10/10)
Super Mario Galaxy
Here you can see they start getting bigger, which means more Boo to love!!! They’re so squishy-looking, I just wanna give ‘em a hug!!! (10/10)
Super Mario 3D World
YOU CAN SEE THROUGH THEM??? STUPENDOUS!!!! Look, they got their tongues out and they’re on the chase! (10/10)
Mario Party (4 and 5)
He’s got a cute little outfit on, oh no my heart can’t take this!!!! I wanna see him do some cool magic tricks, would hire as a birthday wizard!!! (10/10)
Wouldya look at that! This Boo’s gonna gobble up aaaaalll the ice cream!!! Bonus points for first playable Mario Party Boo!!!!! (10/10)
Paper Mario
Ooooo they got very pointy, yes they did! But lookit those eyebrows!! I’d trust them, I mean, look at how expressive they can be!!! (10/10)
But that’s not all!!! Let’s do King Boo to wrap things up!!!
Standard
So round and smooth and soft! And that crown is so sparkly, oh my goodness!! A very Good King!!!! (10/10)
Luigi’s Mansion
His tongue!!! It’s blue!!! And bright red eyes to match that jeweled crown??? Gorgeous!!!! (10/10)
Luigi’s Mansion: Dark Moon
Call me biased, but purple is my Favorite color, making this my Favorite King Boo. That ominous look! Those shadowy eyes!!! I love this!!! (10000/10)
I hope you enjoyed my rating, because simply put, all Boos are good.